Publication Ethics, Corrections, Retractions and Post-Publication Updates

Publication Ethics, Corrections, Retractions and Post-Publication Updates

1. Commitment to Publication Ethics

Tourism & Management Studies is committed to maintaining the integrity, reliability and transparency of the scholarly record. The journal follows internationally recognised principles of publication ethics, particularly those established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Authors, reviewers and editors are expected to uphold high standards of academic integrity throughout the research and publication process. The journal does not tolerate research misconduct, including plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of data, duplicate publication, or deliberate misrepresentation of research findings.

The journal takes concerns about the integrity of published research seriously and undertakes appropriate investigations whenever credible concerns are raised.

2. Post-Publication Responsibilities

The journal recognises that its responsibility for the integrity of published research continues after publication.

Concerns regarding published articles may be raised by readers, researchers, reviewers, editors, institutions or other interested parties. Such concerns may involve the reliability of research findings, the availability and authenticity of research data, errors in statistical analyses, ethical issues, plagiarism, authorship disputes or other matters affecting the integrity of the scholarly record.

The Editors assess these concerns in accordance with the journal's editorial policies and relevant COPE guidance. Authors are normally given an opportunity to provide explanations and supporting documentation before a final decision is reached.

Where appropriate, the Editors may consult the Editorial Advisory Board, independent experts or relevant institutions.

3. Corrections

A correction may be issued when an article contains errors that require amendment but do not invalidate its main findings or conclusions.

Corrections may concern factual inaccuracies, analytical errors, missing or incorrect information, or other issues that can be adequately addressed without retracting the article.

Corrections are published as separate, clearly identifiable notices, normally with their own Digital Object Identifier (DOI), and are linked to the original article.

The original article remains accessible, with a clear indication that a correction has been published.

4. Expressions of Concern

An Expression of Concern may be published when serious questions arise regarding the reliability or integrity of a published article, but the available evidence is insufficient to justify an immediate correction or retraction.

This may occur when an investigation is ongoing, when essential information cannot yet be obtained, or when significant concerns remain unresolved.

An Expression of Concern is clearly identified, linked to the original article and may subsequently be updated, withdrawn or followed by a correction or retraction, depending on the outcome of the investigation.

5. Retractions

A retraction may be necessary when the Editors determine that the findings or conclusions of a published article are unreliable, when serious breaches of research or publication ethics have occurred, or when other circumstances justify the withdrawal of the article from the reliable scholarly record.

Grounds for retraction may include, but are not limited to:

  • Fabrication or falsification of research data or results.

  • Serious errors in data collection, analysis or interpretation that substantially undermine the findings.

  • Plagiarism or substantial unauthorised duplication of previously published material.

  • Duplicate or redundant publication.

  • Serious ethical violations affecting the research or publication process.

  • Inability to provide essential original research data or analysis records where their absence prevents adequate verification of the published findings and gives rise to substantial concerns about their reliability.

A retraction does not necessarily imply that research misconduct has occurred. Articles may be retracted because their findings cannot be considered sufficiently reliable, even when fabrication, falsification or deliberate misconduct has not been established.

Retraction decisions are made by the Editors following an appropriate assessment of the available evidence. The Editorial Advisory Board or independent experts may be consulted when necessary.

Authors are informed of the concerns and normally given an opportunity to respond before the final decision.

6. Retraction Notices and Article Identification

Retractions are communicated through a formal Retraction Notice published on the journal's website.

Each notice:

  • Is clearly identified as a Retraction Notice.

  • Identifies the original article, including its title, authors and DOI.

  • Explains the reasons for the retraction.

  • Identifies the party responsible for the retraction decision.

  • Is freely accessible and assigned its own DOI.

  • Is linked to the original article.

Retracted articles normally remain accessible on the journal's website to preserve the scholarly record. Their status is clearly indicated through a visible RETRACTED label or watermark, together with a link to the corresponding Retraction Notice.

The journal also registers relevant post-publication updates and their relationships with the original articles in Crossref whenever applicable.

7. Article Removal

In exceptional circumstances, the journal may remove the full text of a published article when continued public availability would create serious legal, privacy, safety or ethical risks that cannot reasonably be addressed through a correction or retraction.

Whenever possible, the article's bibliographic information and a notice explaining the reason for removal will remain publicly accessible.

Removal is distinct from retraction and is considered only when justified by exceptional circumstances.

8. Research Data and Verification

Authors are responsible for maintaining the original research data and documentation necessary to substantiate their findings, in accordance with the journal's data retention requirements.

Research data, statistical analysis files, code and other relevant documentation must be preserved for at least five years after publication, subject to applicable legal, ethical and confidentiality requirements.

Where legitimate concerns arise regarding published findings, the Editors may request the original datasets, analysis records or other supporting documentation needed to assess their reliability.

Failure to provide essential research records may affect the journal's ability to verify the published findings and may lead to appropriate editorial action, including an Expression of Concern or retraction when justified.

9. Transparency and Permanent Scholarly Record

Tourism & Management Studies is committed to maintaining an accurate and transparent scholarly record.

Corrections, Expressions of Concern, Retraction Notices and other significant post-publication updates are clearly identified, publicly accessible and linked to the affected publications.

Where applicable, the journal assigns separate DOIs to editorial notices and registers the relationships between updated articles and their corresponding notices with Crossref.

The journal's approach to post-publication updates is informed by the COPE guidelines and the principles underlying Crossref's Crossmark service.

10. Reporting Concerns

Readers, researchers and other interested parties who identify possible errors or concerns regarding the integrity of published articles are encouraged to contact the Editors through the journal's official contact details.

Submissions should identify the article concerned and provide a clear description of the issue, together with any relevant supporting evidence.

All concerns will be assessed carefully, impartially and with appropriate respect for confidentiality and procedural fairness.

11. Relevant Guidelines

The journal's policies are informed by the following international guidance:

  • Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE): Core Practices.

  • Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE): Retraction Guidelines (2025).

  • Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE): Guidance on Expressions of Concern.

  • Crossref: Crossmark and Post-Publication Updates.

The journal reserves the right to revise these policies to reflect developments in international standards of publication ethics and scholarly communication.